“Tell her before she finds out from me,” Megan had texted Greg.

I saw it on his phone two hours after he left, face-up on the floor by our front door. I’d already read the first line twice before I noticed the white pharmacy bag beside it, my full name printed on the label.

I didn’t know then what Megan meant by “it.” I thought I did. I thought she meant the affair.

I was wrong about that.

The morning had been ordinary enough, which is what bothers me now.

I’d picked up my fertility prescription on Friday. The bag was still on the counter, tucked behind the bread box because I didn’t like looking at the label. Greg had said he’d take out the recycling. He hadn’t. The blue bin was still sitting by the garage door.

I remember these things because I’m apparently the kind of person who can remember the recycling and forget the exact date of the appointment that changed my life.

Greg was in our bedroom getting dressed. I heard his belt buckle, then the little cough he did after spraying cologne. He used too much.

The cologne I bought him sat untouched in the bathroom cabinet. This was a different bottle.

I knew Megan liked it because I’d seen the text on his phone the night before.

“Wear the cedar one tomorrow.”

No heart, no kiss, nothing you could point to and call proof by itself. But I’d already found the hotel receipt in his jacket. I’d already seen the late-night messages. I didn’t need to turn into a detective. I just needed to stop lying to myself.

Greg came into the kitchen wearing his blue shirt, the one he called his meeting shirt. He looked rested.

I was annoyed by that. It’s embarrassing to admit, but I wanted him to look guilty before I even said anything.

“Coffee’s ready,” I said.

He took the black mug from the counter. It said BEST HUSBAND in white letters. I bought it at a church craft sale years ago. He used it every morning, though he used to make a joke about the words.

The laxatives were already mixed in.

I’d told myself it was a small thing. A childish thing. Something that would make him late and uncomfortable, not hurt him. I also knew I had no right to decide what was safe to put in somebody else’s drink. I did it anyway.

Greg took three big swallows.

“Where are you headed?” I asked.

“Downtown. Client meeting.”

He didn’t look at me when he said it. I didn’t call him out. I watched him put the mug in the sink, rinse it, and take his keys off the hook.

I hated how familiar all of it looked.

For most of our marriage, Greg had been easy to live with. He made toast on Sundays and brought me the last piece even when he wanted it. He knew I liked the house cool at night and that I hated the little spoon that came with the sugar bowl. When we first started trying for a baby, he sat with me through every appointment.

At least, that’s what I believed.

I was thirty-six when the doctor first said the word “infertility.” I remember the room had a poster about prenatal vitamins and a bowl of peppermints. I took two peppermints because I didn’t know what else to do with my hands.

Greg squeezed my knee under the chair.

“We’ll figure it out,” he said.

I believed him. I also believed the doctor when she said we’d need more tests.

There were blood tests, scans, and one appointment where I had to drink something that tasted like orange chalk. Greg went in for his tests too. He told me they were normal. I never asked to see the paperwork. It didn’t occur to me that he could look at me after an appointment and leave out the one thing that mattered.

We kept trying. We kept paying. We kept telling family we weren’t ready yet, which was easier than telling them we wanted a child and couldn’t have one.

After a while, I stopped telling people anything.

I also stopped noticing when Greg’s patience changed. He’d come home late. He’d answer work calls outside. When I asked about it, he said the company was busy.

“Just a rough quarter,” he’d say.

I wanted to be the kind of wife who trusted her husband. I also wanted to be the kind of wife who didn’t have to check the phone he left by the sink.

I became both.

On Monday, Greg leaned across the kitchen counter and kissed my forehead. He smelled like the cedar cologne.

“Have a good day,” he said.

“Sure.”

He left.

A minute later, I heard him shout from the garage.

“Damn it!”

The sound was loud enough to make me smile. I stood there with one hand on the counter and felt awful about smiling. Then I felt glad I’d done it. Both things were true.

I assumed he’d rushed to the bathroom. I pictured him sitting there, late for his meeting, angry and uncomfortable. I let myself enjoy that for a few seconds.

Then I picked up the pharmacy bag and moved it farther behind the bread box.

I didn’t want to think about why I’d filled the prescription again.

I’d promised myself that if this round didn’t work, I’d stop. That was three rounds ago. I kept saying one more, one more, like the next month was a place where I could finally put down the hope I’d been carrying.

By eleven, I’d gone to the grocery store and stopped at the post office. I remember the woman in front of me had a stack of packages tied up with twine. I remember being irritated that she took so long. I don’t remember what I bought at the store.

When I got home, the front door was open.

Not wide open. Just enough to make me stop on the porch with my keys in my hand. I looked at the latch. Nothing was broken. Greg had probably left in a hurry.

His phone was on the floor inside the door.

I bent to pick it up. The screen lit.

Megan’s name sat above the message.

“I already did what you asked. Now tell your wife the truth.”

There was a second message below it, but the phone locked before I could read it.

The pharmacy bag was beside the phone.

My name was on the label. The refill had been ready since Saturday. I’dI’d barely set the bag down when the doorbell rang three times.

Megan was on the porch. She held out a folded lab report and said, “Greg asked me to give you this.” I didn’t invite her in. I read it right there, with the pharmacy bag still on the table behind me. The test was from years ago. Greg had been told he couldn’t father a child. He’d known before our first appointment, before every refill, before every time he squeezed my knee and said we’d figure it out.

“He said he was going to tell you,” Megan said. “He kept putting it off.”

I wanted to ask how long she’d known. I wanted to ask why she stayed with him. Instead, I told her to go. Greg came home later and found the report on the kitchen counter. I’d called the clinic, canceled the refill, and left the rest of his things by the garage door. I didn’t scream. I didn’t forgive him. I didn’t tell him about the coffee, either. That part is mine to carry.

The next morning, I took the black mug down from the shelf and put it in the trash. The words BEST HUSBAND were facing up.